DEUX RIVES

Philosophy1 Jul 20269 min read

Memento mori, Europe's reminder of Allah!

Stoicism, the purest expression of ancient European spirituality, meets the Islamic remembrance of death.

Ibrāhīm Barbarūs Al-UrubbiDeux Rives

This essay looks at what Islam has been able to revive in the European character. We will begin with an essential and concise definition of Islam, then turn to a European system of thought that shows the compatibility of European and Islamic thought, through an analysis of Stoicism and its development.

Of all the expressions of ancient European spirituality, Stoicism is the one that spread most widely across the empire (from Greece to Rome, from the elites to the slaves), that left the deepest mark on late Roman morality and, above all, that shows the most striking and systematic convergences with the Islamic worldview. It is therefore Stoicism, and not Homeric heroism, too passionate, nor Dionysianism, too ecstatic, nor even Epicureanism, too focused on measured pleasure, that we take here as the purest and most universal vehicle of what pagan Europe produced closest to disinterested virtue and an active memento mori.

This article is therefore addressed mainly to those of our people who wonder, in good faith, about our adherence to this religious current, said to have been born in the land of Arabia (whereas Islam, as the doctrine of divine Oneness (Tawhid), has existed since the creation of humanity, revealed by Allah through His messengers and as an innate fitrah inscribed in every soul). Geographical distance proves nothing to one who is not stuck in material (and materialist) illusion! Europe has never been a stranger to the spiritual verticality (monasteries, orders of knighthood) that Islam brings back. Islam therefore does not appear there as an intruder, but as a reminder of a forgotten wisdom.

Submission to what is True

We turn first to the etymology of the word "Islam" itself, a transcription from Arabic which, as most people know, comes from the idea of "submission (to God)" and "peace, security (in God)". We thus find the idea of refuge and devotion before the ultimate Sovereign. The virile man, in his submission to the Supreme, does not diminish himself, contrary to the ideas spread by our contemporaries (who, incidentally, stand at the opposite extreme from the virile man). The true man, in his submission, is tested and finds himself all the more valued, adopting recognition, gratitude and devotion towards his Creator.

This vision is utterly opposed to the Nietzschean man, resentful towards God, going so far as to suggest that He is "dead". A hysteria of the mind criticised many times by serious metaphysicians such as Julius Evola, who clearly exposed the fragility of nihilist reasoning.

These criticisms can be extended not only to Nietzscheans but also to sceptics, a current entirely stripped of meaning.

They can be likened to the atheists who claim it, refusing to believe they had a Creator who must be worshipped and granting this creative faculty only to "Mother Nature". She is supposedly the source of the trees, which they admire even when they are destroyed by Man, and of the green expanses on which they stub out their cigarettes.

These homo hystericus place blind faith in "Science", yet cannot state a single one of its principles when asked. They never place themselves above true believers, since these atheists grant their beliefs a theoretical status. This paradox reveals a self-critical stupidity. The symptom of an age sick from no longer knowing how to tell arrogance from lucidity!

The believer, in his superiority, lives God as if He were materially at his side. He does not need eyes to see Him, nor ears to hear Him. He carries within him the imprint of divine creation.

This is why belief in God brings peace. Not because it is one way of obtaining peace, as some claim that religions merely look for a meaning to life, but because it is the only way to obtain true peace. It is the only way to know the meaning of life. And to those who, outraged by this statement, question it with virulence and mockery, we answer scientifically: science has never found a meaning to life. Islam has recalled it!

Only one who has truly experienced it can understand. The others are no better than spectators at a sports match discussing how they would have played in the player's place. There are those who act and those who watch. The former are not sure of the place they will take on the podium, but the latter would be foolish to imagine themselves there. So it is not with the spectators who see themselves as players that we will try to reason.

Islam is not "research" or "theory"; it is revelation, the final decree. It is submission before the Truth and therefore, ultimately, before God (Al-Haqq). Islamic man is driven to action, and in his action he has the duty to contemplate.

"And on the earth are signs for those who are certain in faith. And in yourselves. Then will you not see?" (Quran 51:20-21)

Contemplation is not only an ability; it is a duty. A duty of remembrance, we might say. The whole universe is a monument to the divine work. How can so many humans go into raptures contemplating paintings without marvelling at the One who breathed life into those artists? The only One who can be called Creator, since He is the origin of All, and without Him there is nothing. The artist invented nothing, created nothing. He used the elements at his disposal to assemble.

Islam is therefore, eminently, a revelation that stresses remembrance, and an essential remembrance, unavoidable despite every attempt. Impossible to miss even for one who would rather not see it: the reminder that we are all going to die.

Memento mori, the European virtue

All of life is but a journey towards death, said Seneca. Other quotations would only further highlight the Stoics' invitation to manage our time according to the end of our life. Let us therefore order each day as if it were to close the march, as if it were the end of our life and its supreme conclusion.

These wise words, spoken within Stoicism, could legitimately be mistaken for the reported sayings of our beloved Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him).

Indeed, according to Anas Ibn Malik (may Allah be pleased with him), the Prophet (may the prayer and peace of Allah be upon him) said:

"Remember death in your prayer [...]. Pray the prayer of a man who thinks he will not pray again after this prayer [...]."

Stoicism is a European school of thought which, like Islam, insists on managing time towards good works, right action and preparation for death.

From Zeno to Marcus Aurelius, there would be many quotations to argue for the closeness between European thought and Islam, and we will have the opportunity to set them out in more detail in future publications. For now, let us highlight a few parallels to nourish the reader.

First, Stoicism holds a deep rejection of hedonism, which makes pleasure man's main goal, in favour of the primacy of right action. Stoicism does not merely reject; it also embraces the idea of amor fati (qadar), love of fate: accepting what happens, not out of resignation, arms folded, but out of love, arms open to the divine will!

In his Meditations, Marcus Aurelius offers an interesting reflection on the reasons to love the events that test us throughout our life:

"You must therefore love what happens to you for two reasons. The first, because it was made for you, suited you, and came to you, as it were, from above, from the chain of the most ancient causes. The second, because what happens to each particular being contributes to the good order, the perfection and the very continuance of the One who governs universal nature."

A passage that blends with this prophetic saying: "When Allah wills good for someone, He tests him", underlining that trials are a proof of God's love. They purify our souls, expiate our sins and bring us closer to Him.

Life is nothing, death is the beginning of everything: this is the Stoic formula to remember, a sufficient but necessary reminder to measure the abyss that separates us from the modern world. It is therefore no surprise that the modern world rejects Islam.

Our contemporaries, especially over the last century, have fully adopted the adage carpe diem: seize the present day without worrying about tomorrow. An ostrich strategy that has only produced the inescapable chaos in which we find ourselves, although one can be in this world without belonging to it.

It is the insatiable hedonism of our most recent ancestors that is the cause of this decadence. Decadence in the domain of faith, but also across all the domains that touch Western man (and above all Westernised man, understood as a system of thought rather than a geographical label).

It is not a search for what is right, for truth, or even for true happiness. No room for virtue, nor for action, nor for community. In the name of what are these values repudiated? Material happiness! Individualism! Passivity! Baseness! As long as fruit can be gathered, no matter if it is poisoned, since no one cares about death, so long as it tastes good!

Traditional Europe was not founded on this repugnant system of values, nor did it anchor its history in it, through its discoveries rather than its barbarities (too often evangelical, incidentally). If we look at history and blow the dust off our ancient codes: Roman fides (the value given to one's word), Roman virtue (duty to the divine, the family, the city), Germanic warrior morality (found in the Männerbund!), the guilds, whose solidarity and measures to protect everyone's interest cannot be denied! From Plato to Marcus Aurelius, the quest for the Good, virtue and living in accordance with God! These elements show clearly that Europe was not born of selfishness, greed, consumption or destruction. This modern conception of Europe is merely the product of a historical revision by the Davos forum. All these evils are fruits planted by sick minds, destined to be harvested by a perverse and antagonistic system. This system has been exploited by depraved elites to extinguish men's capacity to act for good. Thus deprived, illusorily, of their power of decision, they are condemned to act for ill. For failing to act, when one has the strength, is already a fault for anyone who calls himself a man! Here before our eyes is the fracture of our age.

In the end, this short essay had only one aim: to recall that Islam is not a foreign body set down upon Europe, but the echo of a wisdom this continent carried long before it forgot it. Submission to the True, awareness of death, the demand for virtue, right action and contemplation: all of this already formed the backbone of traditional European thought.

Stoicism was only one expression of it among others, and Islam is today its purest reminder.

Those who claim to set Europe against Islam understand neither one nor the other. They do not know that truth has never been private property, still less a flag. Islam is not European by geography, but by verticality. It speaks to the man who refuses baseness, who refuses lies, who seeks the Truth wherever it may be. If Europe wants to remain faithful to what it was, not a land of hedonism but of strength, lucidity and honour, then it can only recognise in Islam a mirror of its oldest values.

For Truth is not invented: it is rediscovered.

And when it is rediscovered, it resonates. Even across the centuries. Even across lands. Even through the prophets.

Islam, through its intransigence towards the True, through its call to conscious death and right action, is far closer to traditional Europe than modern ideologies will ever be. That is why it is not an intruder: it is a final reminder.